By Selin Dilli (UU) and Niklas Elert (IFN):

Europe’s economic problems have led many policymakers to recognize that institutional reforms to foster entrepreneurship and economic growth are needed in the 28 member countries of the European Union. To be successful, reform strategies must be informed by a sound understanding of the diversity of European capitalism and the institutional structures that drive these differences.

A common reform approach is to identify a country that appears to be performing well in a particular institutional dimension and to promote this institution in other countries. This kind of best-practice-approach ignores the fact that each country has developed its unique bundle of institutions, which complement each other. Reform strategies that ignore such institutional complementarities risk doing more harm than good. This challenge may explain, for example, why European imitation of policies aimed at stimulating venture capital has been unsuccessful (e.g., European Commission 2013).[i]

Institutions are complementary if the presence or efficiency of one institution increases the returns from or efficiency of the other. Institutional complementarities imply that viable policy changes must be compatible with the existing institutional composition. We know from the literature that there may be more than one institutional form that can result in good economic outcomes.

Our study covers 21 European countries and includes the United States as a point of comparison because it is considered successful in terms of entrepreneurship. We analyze countries’ entrepreneurial climate, and institutions relevant to this climate, based on data from 2000 onwards. We include indicators on informal institutions (norms and attitudes), political and economic institutions, labor market institutions and social protection systems, as well as the institutions that underpin knowledge and education.

In order to examine whether and how these institutions support each other various statistical techniques are employed, namely principal component analysis to produce a minimum number of uncorrelated and orthogonal principal components, and cluster analysis to identify how countries group along these dimensions. We find six different country clusters and each cluster has a distinct bundle of entrepreneurial and institutional attributes.

Six country clusters

Our results are in part consistent with previous typologies proposed in the literature, but with several important differences. A first cluster consists of the US, UK, and Ireland. These countries combine good legal systems with an emphasis on small government, prioritize investment funds, have low pension replacement rates, high governmental expenditure on education and moderate school enrollment, and value individualism, long-term orientations, and masculinity. However, the three countries differ with respect to their entrepreneurial regimes: the United Kingdom has little necessity-based new ventures and moderate opportunity entrepreneurship in new and established activities, whereas Ireland has high necessity-based nascent activity, and the United States has a large amount of both.

The Nordic countries form another group and are similar in terms of all the institutional dimensions and entrepreneurial regimes. This group has good legal systems and large governments, prioritizes investment funds, has high governmental expenditure on education and pension replacement rates. Countries in this group have relatively little necessity-based nascent entrepreneurship and moderate levels of opportunity-entrepreneurship in new and established businesses.

Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Austria are a group with an entrepreneurial regime akin to the Nordic model but with a different bundle of institutions. They have high-quality legal systems, high governmental expenditure on research and education, and value individualism, long-term orientation, and masculinity. Belgium and France are similar in all dimensions and therefore form a separate group. These two countries have low levels of nascent necessity-based entrepreneurship and opportunity entrepreneurship in new and established businesses. They have low pension replacement rates, high government expenditure on education and modest school enrollment, a preference for uncertainty avoidance, and a high-quality legal system.

Germany is grouped with the Mediterranean countries as a result of its entrepreneurial regime with low levels of opportunity entrepreneurship while it shows similarities to Continental Europe in terms of its institutional structure. The Eastern European countries are relatively similar in terms of all the dimensions and form a final group. They have moderate to low-quality legal systems and high social spending, especially on health. This group is characterized by necessity-based nascent activity (though in Slovenia this is less obvious).

We, thus, highlight the existence of different institutional structures and entrepreneurial regimes in Europe. This implies that one-size-fits-all reform strategies are likely to fail. Member countries in different clusters must instead follow various reform strategies on how best to promote entrepreneurship and economic growth. It may, for example, be reasonable to use the United States as a reference point when formulating reform strategies for Ireland and the UK, but the reforms for the countries of the other groupings must be based on strategies that are tailored to them. For instance, since 2014, Danish Growth Capital, a government investment fund, has aimed to improve access to risk capital for entrepreneurs and SMEs by using pension funds (OECD 2015).[ii] This model could be a strategy for financial institutions of the other Nordic countries to follow.

Our study, however, provides a snapshot of institutions over a limited time period. It is important to differentiate between slow moving institutions and more rapidly changing ones for better reform strategies. The history of institutional evolution has been far from unidirectional, and institutional reversals are common throughout history. In the future, the FIRES project hopes to explore these historical contingencies in more detail.

This blog is written based on a research carried out by Dilli and Elert (2016). Further information on this research is available at Dilli, Selin and Niklas Elert. (2016) “The Diversity of Entrepreneurial Regimes in Europe.” SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network, March 21, 2016. http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2752966.

[i]European Commission (2013). Entrepreneurship 2020 Action Plan: Reigniting the Entrepreneurial Spirit in Europe. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

[ii] OECD (2015a). Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs 2015. Paris: OECD.

Comments
  • Ambroseshoca
    Reply

    Beautiful girls are looking for sex in your city: http://v.ht/NWX3H?&excvx=eAeQhrKpQ4l0MC

    Popular tags: download gratis novel santhy agatha dating with the dark, gay hookup apps london, asian speed dating tips, atomic dating using isotopes lab report answers, cheating dating site uk, asian dating service nyc, seven days vt dating, dispatch korea dating 2016, online dating demographics 2012, best funny dating profiles, sweet things to do for a guy you’re dating, free christian dating sites in kenya, 100 free romanian dating site, dating old photographs by clothing, catch matchmaking orange county, dating guild d25, online dating savannah, dating asia site, marriage not dating 3 eng sub, hilarious dating fails, internet dating in polokwane, hook up sites yahoo, best dating profile ever written, my mom is dating a crackhead, oitnb poussey dating, dating zeiss binoculars, dating niche sites, how long after dating should you become a couple, casual dating washington dc, derbyshire mature dating, how to do dating online, gay dating sites kent, dating apps for indian, free dating site in uk 2013, dating length before engagement, dating website money, craigslist dating augusta ga, difference between relative dating and radioactive dating, free no subscription online dating, online dating service comparison, muslim turkish dating sites, dating online dating, hook up lloydminster, dating site niches, russian dating site fails, online dating med school, dating service philippines, dating in pakistan, guildford dating sites, free dating sites for married man, tytut dating, levels of dating, african singles dating, rainbow christian dating, dating site windhoek, taurus woman dating capricorn man, who is dating on dancing with the stars 2012, top online hookup sites, matchmaking costa rica, dating indian girl, rio vista dating, dating okanagan, most legitimate online dating site, dating palembangan, dating sites in glasgow, dating geographia maps, free online hookup australia, best website for dating free, absolute vs relative dating methods, nr1 dating site, full hookup camping indiana, mymatch – build your own dating websites, local gay dating sites chesterfield, dating in cebu city, best free dating sites for 40 plus, outdoor enthusiast dating site, best dating email examples, my daughter is dating an old man, dating sites with free pictures, speed dating comic, duggar rules for dating and sex, online russian dating service, free black dating sites in uk, propane grill hookup house, sinopsis crayon dating agency, banglore dating aunties, older man dating website, dating agencies in gloucestershire, scottish borders dating, filling out a dating profile example, traditional dating is dead, astrology.com match making, dating capricorn, best dating sites of uk, hook up victoria, dating tijuana mexico, executive dating agencies london, dating woman with herpes, what to expect when dating a bipolar man, free dating sites bali, palestine dating site, erste nachricht online dating beispiel, carbon dating mount st helens, dating site online chat, all dating site in world, what dating site has the highest success rate, storm dating karen, military officer dating websites, doc love dating, online dating sites largest, hook up coworker, top 20 most popular dating sites, uae dating sites free, ar/ar dating cost, dating for stoners uk, do second base dating, internet dating safety precautions, redneck dating site commercial, free dating games, kostenloses dating portal, 10 things to know about dating a capricorn, nhs dating pregnancy, legal separation and dating in va, best uk dating sites 2014, dating scan appointment, are there any dating apps that actually work, nitanati matchmaking part 19, gay dating singapore, dating a personal trainer, speed dating north jersey, craigslist binghamton dating, strictly come dancing pasha dating, hook up brain gym, africa dating customs, gay dating sites vietnam, sunday times dating online, fwb dating someone else, dating a guy and he’s still online, love dating websites, introductory message dating site, dating makeup tips, skout dating websites, no sign up dating uk, top young dating sites, affairs dating, dating headlines samples, dating event bristol, christian dating biblical advice, list of old dating shows, shim hyung tak dating, funny dating pictures, ian somerhalder dating life, dating it’s complicated cat lady, carbon dating calculations, chat online free dating indonesia, robert shark tank dating dancing with the stars, why am i so weird about dating, speed dating das spiel, dating shy girl, bates dating rules, harry are you and louis dating, cebu dating agency, dating services richmond va, dating advice 101, hoboken nj speed dating, who created online dating, hookup portland, gay speed dating cape town, stanathan dating, black girl dating a white guy in south africa, my ex is dating someone else and it’s killing me, best dating website adelaide, i am dating my second cousin, good online dating profiles, ideas for dating headlines, dating busy schedule, online dating peinlich, free matchmaking websites, speed dating events today, indian dating and marriage customs, australian gay dating sites, dating coach new zealand, lithuanian dating ireland, suggested dating site usernames, birthday gift ideas for boyfriend just started dating, kisumu dating site, how to go from friends to dating with a girl, texas dating planet, russisch vrouwen dating, speed dating tukwila, dating peruvian guy, countryside dating websites, choctaw indian dating, lunch date online dating, ahs i’m dead wanna hook up shirt, best free european online dating sites, dating site spanish, shirtless pictures on dating sites, uk online dating sites, friends dating your ex boyfriend quotes, executive dating perth, dating ben pearson bows, online dating relationship timeline, top internet dating websites, dating site for iphone users, how to know if you are dating a control freak, gay dating in gurgaon, dating cleveland, 30 year old woman dating 20 year old, what are the top online dating sites, female dating profile template, interracial dating in minneapolis, first contact online dating, lviv girl dating, free dating sites peterborough ontario, speed dating over 50 new york, exclusive dating talk, hong kong dating free sites, uk dating agencies free, dating antique table legs, dating sites for ravers, free dating sites like flirtomatic, queer ladies speed dating, how many wires hook up to a starter, 30’s dating site, hookup sites reddit, top korean dating sites, your dating headline examples, epilepsy dating site, modern dating tips, how do you hook up a voltage regulator, speed dating jacksonville, dating online live, dating ukraine girls, haitian dating customs, good first message to send to a girl on a dating site, e dating exposed cast, syracuse ny speed dating, tucson dating services, dating website in delhi, dating kabar pocket knives, best hookup apps london, delaware dating sites, best free online dating apps 2015, empire cookie and luscious hook up, are kristen stewart and robert pattinson dating 2013, idaho falls dating, law of attraction dating sites, best online dating sites los angeles 2014, which of the following principles are key to relative dating quizlet, bipolar romantic relationships dating and marriage, indian dating apps ios, soldiers online dating uk

Leave a Reply to Ambroseshoca Cancel reply